[Verse 1]
Funny how it hit me in the middle of the night
I’ve been taking every answer like you wouldn’t rewrite
Like your word was something solid, like your mouth came with proof
Then I remembered all the times you looked at me and lied
Said “present and future” with one foot out the door
Said you loved me, swore you’d never do that anymore
Then you left to see another girl like nothing that you said
Was supposed to mean a damn thing once it left your head
[Pre-Chorus]
And damn, I really trusted you
That might be the dumbest thing I do
[Chorus]
404, no response found
Funny how the truth gets quiet when I call it out
I gave you every benefit, you gave me every doubt
Now I’m finally putting two and two together now
404, no response found
Maybe you’re not lying, maybe no one’s been around
But I know what you’re capable of, that’s the bitter truth
And somehow after everything
I still believed in you
[Verse 2]
I believed you when you told me there was nobody around
No flirting, no late-night girl, nobody coming down
While I’m trying to support you, showing up and being kind
Never stopping once to wonder what you’re doing behind mine
And I told you how I felt, you barely made a sound
Guess vulnerability gets lost when you’re not looking down
You had somebody who knew exactly what you’d done
And still chose grace instead of making you become
The villain you’d already been
[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe hope just made me blind
Or maybe you got good at wasting mine
[Chorus]
404, no response found
Funny how the truth gets quiet when I call it out
I gave you every benefit, you gave me every doubt
Now I’m finally putting two and two together now
404, no response found
Maybe you’re not lying, maybe no one’s been around
But I know what you’re capable of, that’s the bitter truth
And somehow after everything
I still believed in you
[Bridge]
You were lucky
God, you were lucky
I knew what you did and I still wasn’t cruel
Tell me honestly, if I had done it to you
Would you give me half the grace
That I kept giving you?
Yeah, I didn’t think so
[Breakdown]
And that’s the part that should hurt the most
You didn’t fool somebody who didn’t know
I knew
And stayed
I hurt
And gave
I saw the worst
And still had faith
What a waste
[Final Chorus]
404, no response found
I don’t need another answer, I can read you now
I gave you every reason to become somebody new
You gave me every reason not to trust a word from you
404, no response found
You had someone who believed when there was reason to doubt
Maybe I was foolish, maybe way too hopeful too
But I’d rather be the idiot who loved
Than be somebody like you
[Outro]
You had someone who believed in you
After everything you put them through
And somehow
You didn’t value it
404
No response found