[Verse 1]
One man laughs like summer, calls me late at night,
Shows me little projects saying, “Everything’s alright.”
One man leaves me guessing, never sticks around,
Turns a room that’s full of love into a ghost town.
One man knows my coffee, knows my favorite song,
One man makes me question if I ever belonged.
I kept asking everybody, “Which one should I choose?”
Didn’t know that either way… I’d end up losing.
[Pre-Chorus]
Tell me which one’s real…
Which one do I believe?
[Chorus]
One man picks me flowers,
One man picks a fight.
One man swears he’ll catch me,
One lets go outright.
One man drives for cheesecake
Just to make me smile.
One hears me crying on the couch…
And says, “Hold on a while…”
He’s got somebody else to call.
[Verse 2]
One man writes about his children, makes the whole room cry,
One can watch the tears roll down and never bat an eye.
One man says, “I got you,” wraps a blanket ’round my heart,
One can walk right past the pieces while they fall apart.
One man makes me feel like home every single day,
One man makes me wonder why that home keeps slipping away.
Everybody tells me, “Girl, you’ve gotta choose…”
If only they knew…
[Bridge]
Maybe I was crazy.
Maybe I was blind.
Maybe that’s what happens
When two worlds share one life.
How could someone so gentle
Feel so far apart?
How could two different strangers
Fit inside one heart?
[Final Chorus - The Reveal]
Turns out there weren’t two men.
There never even were.
The one who brought the cheesecake…
The one who made it hurt.
The one who held my future,
The one who let me fall.
I spent all this time choosing…
They were the same man after all.
[Outro]
I wasn’t caught between two lovers…
I was caught between two versions…
Of one.
