I Love You Still

When we first met

I thought it was love at first sight

At least to me

Only to me

I was so young

Didn’t know what it meant yet

You were funny

Charming

I couldn’t forget

I told her about you

Before you knew her name

Didn’t think she’d ever

Look at you that way

You were cocky

Overconfident

And I loved you still

You never knew

You were holding her

While I was right there

She knew the truth

And I think it hurt her too

But she loved you still

She was my best friend

Knew every part of me

Every time I said

What you meant to me

I showed her your face

Said “isn’t he everything?”

Guess I didn’t know

What that would bring

I saw it change

In the way she’d smile

The way she said your name

Like I used to

You were cocky

Overconfident

And I loved you still

You never knew

You were holding her

While I was right there

She knew I cared

Knew I loved you first, and I know she did

But she loved you still

I watch you watch her

Like she’s all you see

And she looks back

Like she’s scared to look at me

I tried to be mad

But it never stayed

‘Cause I love you both

In a different way

You were cocky

Overconfident

And I loved you still

You never knew

How I broke every time you chose her

But I stayed so still

She was my best friend

And I miss who we were before all this

But I love her still

When we first met

I thought it was love at first sight

At least to me

And somehow

Even now

I love you both