[Verse 1]
Met her in the hallway, laughing at the wrong time
Coffee on her shirt, still calling it a good sign
Lucy with the wild hair, circles under tired eyes
Said, “I don’t sleep much, but I’m doing fine”
We shared playlists, cheap fries, late rides
You rant, I drive, that’s our late-night pastime
You said, “Promise me you’ll stay till the sunrise”
I said, “I’m here, long as you keep those eyes wide”
[Chorus]
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
You don’t see what I see inside
Every scar, every tear you hide
Still you shine, yeah you shine so bright
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
You say “just friends,” I say “alright”
But my heart keeps crossing that line
‘Cause I’m in love with my best friend’s smile
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes (oh-oh)
[Verse 2]
You call when you’re broken, I show up in old sweats
You talk about strangers like they’re your best bets
You cry on my shoulder, then laugh till it all dries
Wiping black lines from under your eyes
You say I’m your safe place, soft place to land
You hold my face, thank me, squeeze my hand
I joke, “You’ll owe me when we’re old and gray”
You say, “We’ll still be friends, that’ll never change”
[Chorus]
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
You don’t see what I see inside
Every scar, every tear you hide
Still you shine, yeah you shine so bright
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
You say “just friends,” I say “alright”
But my heart keeps crossing that line
‘Cause I’m in love with my best friend’s smile
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes (yeah)
[Bridge]
If I told you the truth one night
Would it ruin the laughs, the rides?
Would you pull your hand from mine
Or pull me closer, whisper “finally”?
[Chorus]
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
You don’t see what I see inside
Every scar, every tear you hide
Still you shine, yeah you shine so bright
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes
If it stays friends, I’ll still be by your side
But my heart’s been yours this whole time
I’m in love with my best friend’s smile
Lucy, beautiful, beautiful eyes (oh Lucy)