Verse 1
I gave You every benefit of doubt
Called every silence something working out
I made excuses for the empty space
Said, “Maybe this is timing, maybe this is grace”
I held the words I thought You gave to me
Like they were stronger than what I could see
First heart broke, second learned to wait
Now I'm on my third one wondering if it's too late
Pre-Chorus
I'm not asking You to move the stars
Or write Your name across the dark
There's only one thing left to do
If what I heard from You was true
Chorus
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
Take the promise from the fire
Show me what the waiting's worth
I believed when there was nothing
I stayed when staying hurt
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
But God, You better hurry
'Cause my heart has learned to change
And if You finally give me what I prayed for
I might not want it the same
Verse 2
I used to watch the door like You were near
Turn every little sign into “He's still here”
I thought the ending had already been written
So I kept calling losing him a temporary distance
But somewhere in the endless in-between
I became somebody I had never seen
Gold filled the places where I came apart
And I stopped needing someone else to save my heart
Pre-Chorus
Maybe You were working all along
Maybe I wasn't wrong to hold on
But there's a truth I can't erase—
Waiting changes what it saves
Chorus
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
Take the promise from the fire
Show me what the waiting's worth
I believed beyond the breaking
Till believing started to hurt
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
But God, You better hurry
'Cause I'm not who used to wait
And if You finally give me what I prayed for
You might already be too late
Bridge
What if the answer comes tomorrow
And I don't need it anymore?
What if the girl who begged You for him
Isn't who You're answering for?
What if You were never lying?
What if every word was true?
What if You finally bring him back
And I've already made it through?
My first heart would've run to him
My second would've stayed
But this third heart learned to beat alone
While waiting for You to explain
Final Chorus
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
Pull the promise from the ashes
Show me what the waiting was worth
I believed beyond the breaking
I carried hope until it hurt
If You wanna prove You're not a liar
You just have to make it work
But God, You better hurry
'Cause this heart won't always wait
You could finally give me what I prayed for
And still arrive too late
Outro
First heart loved him.
Second heart waited.
Third heart learned to live without him.
So if You're gonna prove it…
Don't be too late.