[Verse 1]
You say I’m yours
But you’re in her bed
Tell me your stories
Then leave me on read
You call me “home”
But keep changing your address
I hold my breath
You hold her instead
[Chorus]
You say you love me
Then you run to her
Every time she calls
I come in third
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
You keep my heart like a spare key
Baby
Open her door
Then you lock me out
Maybe
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
(alone with you)
[Verse 2]
You swear you’re “done”
Then she cries
You go
I watch you leave
Like a late-night show
You kiss my neck
But her name’s on your tongue
I’m in your arms
But I’m not the one
[Chorus]
You say you love me
Then you run to her
Every time she calls
I come in third
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
You keep my heart like a spare key
Baby
Open her door
Then you lock me out
Maybe
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
(alone with you)
[Bridge]
How do I miss you
When you never really stay?
How am I “all you need”
If I’m last place anyway?
You say I’m yours
But we both know the truth
You’re holding her
While I’m holding on to you
[Chorus]
You say you love me
Then you run to her
Every time she calls
I come in third
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
You keep my heart like a spare key
Baby
Open her door
Then you lock me out
Maybe
Feeling in love
But I’m alone
Alone
(alone with you, alone)