[Verse 1 - Him]
Saw you standing by the arcade light
Lost my words on a Friday night
Everybody else looked cool somehow
I just stared and forgot how
To be normal
[Verse 2 - Her]
Saw you looking then you looked away
Doing that almost every day
You were cute when you got nervous
Guess you never noticed
[Pre-Chorus - Both]
Oh no
Here we go
Everybody knows
Except us
[Chorus - Both]
You were my first crush
My first “what if”
My first stupid song
I couldn’t quit
You were the reason
I stayed up late
Writing your name
On everything
Maybe it’s dumb
Maybe it’s fate
Maybe we were always gonna end this way
[Verse 3 - Him]
Learned guitar just to look more cool
Still looked like a total fool
Played the same three chords for months
Hoping you would hear one once
[Verse 4 - Her]
Heard them all from my bedroom wall
Honestly, they weren’t bad at all
Told my friends I’d marry you
Back when we were seventeen and clueless too
[Pre-Chorus - Both]
Oh no
There we go
Now everybody knows
[Chorus - Both]
You were my first crush
My first “what if”
My first stupid song
I couldn’t quit
You were the reason
I stayed up late
Writing your name
On everything
Maybe it’s dumb
Maybe it’s fate
Maybe we were always gonna end this way
[Bridge - Him]
I thought you wanted somebody cooler
[Bridge - Her]
I thought you wanted somebody else
[Bridge - Both]
Funny how we spent all that time
Scared of asking for ourselves
[Final Chorus - Both]
You were my first crush
My first mistake
The best thing
I was too scared to say
You were the reason
The reason I stayed
And every dumb song
Still sounds the same
Maybe it’s dumb
Maybe it’s fate
Maybe we were always gonna end this way
JOREN
