[Intro]
[Verse]
We were sitting by the fire
Cuddled up in the cold
The warmth from you couldn't outdo the warmth in my heart
We were so happy
And we had fallen in love
Should've known something that good couldn't last
[Verse]
I knew something was off
I asked and you replied
I've started dating someone else
With tears I cried
Why why why?!
You replied,
I'm going to try out this life
but I want you to stay
[Break]
[Chorus]
Just when I thought nothing could change
Just when I thought you and I were forever
Just when i thought I knew you
Is just when I realized...
I fell in love with someone who wasn't you.
[Break]
[Verse]
With tears in my eyes I gave you one last hug
How could you cheat on me with a man?
I won't compete against him
I hope you see one day
how you've hurt everyone who loves you
Just know I'm leaving
and I will move on
[Bridge]
I never truly healed
I never truly thought
that I'd ever be able to move on from you
The love I have for you was so strong
But when it comes to you
It wasn't me at all
[Chorus]
Just when I thought nothing could change
Just when I thought you and I were forever
Just when i thought I knew you
Is just when I realized...
I fell in love with someone who wasn't you.