[Verse 1]
You asked me my favorite flower, I said I didn’t know
Still you made a bouquet, hoping I’d show
I stayed home, too shy to face the night
But you sent me love wrapped in colors and light
[Verse 2 – Halloween Night]
We talked through screens, hearts half-revealed You had someone, so I kept mine sealed
But that Halloween night, we sat on the stairs Confessed our hearts in the cool night air
And when we hugged before heading home
It felt so right—like I’d never been alone
[Chorus]
You asked if you'd ever have a chance with me
I said no, but I didn’t mean it truthfully
Now you're gone, and I’m stuck in yesterday Thinking 'bout the chance I didn’t take
[Verse 3]
You posted The Secret History, I read it just to feel close
Every line a shadow of the girl I miss the most Greek tragedies and twisted fate
I lived your story, but I came too late
[Bridge]
I can't stop thinking about you
Since the day we stopped to talk
Since the night I told you no
I can't stop thinking about you
Can't get you out of my head
Even though I tried so many times
Even though I tried so many nights
To get over you
But this never really ended
It was the right soul, the wrong time
You're my soulmate, my twin flame still burning in my mind
[Chorus]
You asked if you'd ever have a chance with me
I said no, but I didn’t mean it truthfully
Now you're hers, and I’m stuck in yesterday Thinking 'bout the chance I didn’t take
[Outro]
Maybe in another life, I’d be brave
Maybe I’d show up, maybe I’d stay
But for now, I just replay
The chance...
The chance I didn’t take
