[Verse 1]
You call at ten, she calls at two
I keep my lies in a clean-slate blue
Same cologne, different room
Same excuse, same doomed moon
I got one hand on the door
One hand on a promise I ignore
You look at me like I’m still true
I look away, I lie to you
[Pre-Chorus]
I said I’d change
I said it plain
But the same old name
Keeps on winning again
One text, two hearts
That’s where it starts
I’m split in half
And I broke it apart
[Chorus]
Two girls, one lie
I don’t know why
(why, why)
Two girls, one heart
Tearing me apart
I want you both
That’s the crime
(crime, crime)
Two girls, one lie
And I’m out of time
[Verse 2]
She leaves a mark on my skin
You smell perfume when you walk in
I’m good at talking, bad at choosing
Good at winning, worse at losing
You ask me straight, I dodge the truth
I build my house on a sinking roof
Every kiss is a borrowed flame
Every “I love you” sounds the same
[Pre-Chorus]
I said I’d change
I said it plain
But the same old name
Keeps on winning again
One touch, two worlds
Spinning in curls
I’m split in half
And I caused these pearls
[Chorus]
Two girls, one lie
I don’t know why
(why, why)
Two girls, one heart
Tearing me apart
I want you both
That’s the crime
(crime, crime)
Two girls, one lie
And I’m out of time
[Bridge]
Now the truth sits down at my table
Looks me dead in the eyes, says I’m unable
To keep both flames and call it love
To hold two hands and still rise above
So if you leave, I’ll know I earned it
If she stays, I still don’t deserve it
I made this mess with my own two hands
Now I’m the one who don’t understand
[Chorus]
Two girls, one lie
I don’t know why
(why, why)
Two girls, one heart
Tearing me apart
I want you both
That’s the crime
(crime, crime)
Two girls, one lie
And I’m out of time