[Verse 1]
Cake on the table, candles burned black
Your name in the frosting, then I took it back
Another year gone, another hour stole
I wore my best smile like a hole in the soul
[Pre-Chorus]
You said make a wish
I said I did
I wished for less hurt
And more of a lid
[Chorus]
Birthday yes
Happy never
Blow those flames out
Leave them there forever
Birthday yes
Happy never
Same old pain
Just dressed up clever
[Verse 2]
Paper hats fold like a bad alibi
Plastic cups rattlin' when the bottle runs dry
The whole room claps like they mean me no harm
But the love in this house got a handle on the alarm
[Pre-Chorus]
You said cut the cake
I said cut me in
Let the sweet thing rot
Where the truth has been
[Chorus]
Birthday yes
Happy never
Blow those flames out
Leave them there forever
Birthday yes
Happy never
Same old pain
Just dressed up clever
[Bridge]
I blew out twenty, then thirty more
Each one went dark like a slammed screen door
If I keep count, I'll keep the scar
So I let the smoke climb where the bruises are
[Final Chorus]
Birthday yes
Happy never
Blow those flames out
Leave them there forever
Birthday yes
Happy never
Same old pain
Just dressed up clever