

Prompt / Lyrics
(Verse 1 ) My first friend in fifth grade, when I was new in town Name like Loretta Lynn’s father, always hanging around You were the first place in my heart, first one to make it race Didn’t know what love was then, just knew I loved your face (Verse 2) Working with you was such a good time Always making me laugh on the long-day grind You’d joke around and tease me, say I should bark on cue I laughed it off and hid it, but God, I wanted you (Pre-Chorus) Every chapter, every crush Another boy I couldn’t touch (Chorus) A gay man with crushes Yeah, what’s new? I’m a gay boy in love with another Straight dude Yeah, a gay boy with a crush Funny, tragic fate Always wanting somebody Who could never feel the same (Verse 3) Best friends for a year, what a blur All I remember are feelings and unspoken words Truth or dare got us kisses when we were alone But could there have been more? I guess I’ll never know (Verse 4 ) I emailed this guy, asked him on a date He said, “Sorry bro, I only like blonde babes” Read that line a hundred times, tried hard not to cry Wondering why I’m always the wrong kind of guy (Pre-Chorus) Every chapter, every crush Another almost, never us (Chorus) A gay man with crushes Yeah, what’s new? I’m a gay boy in love with another Straight dude Yeah, a gay boy with a crush Funny, tragic fate Always wanting somebody Who could never feel the same (Verse 5) Locker rooms still haunt me, even to this day ’Cause you thought it was funny to mess with me that way You touched me and flirted, said you liked me too Then laughed behind my back because I was a dude Why did you enjoy all those twisted games? I would’ve gave you the world, but you just gave me shame (Bridge) So many guys, so little time So many crushes I buried inside ’Cause in a small town, all I ever knew Was falling for boys who’d never want me too Never gay, always straight Every hallway, every heartbreak Still I keep on hoping, even after all I’ve been through Maybe someday there’ll be a boy Who wants me like I want him too (Final Chorus) A gay man with crushes Yeah, what’s new? But maybe one day I’ll find somebody Who comes through And I won’t be the gay boy Chasing another straight dude I’ll be somebody’s first choice And he’ll love me too
Tags
Pop country, acoustic, soft guitar, male vocals, intimate, storytelling, passionate, emotional
3:24
No
3/31/2026