Verse 1)
I still lock my doors out of habit now
Even when nobody’s around
You taught me people leave quietly
Without making a sound
You said forever like you meant every word
Now forever’s just something I heard
And I swear I was better before
I knew how easy love could burn
(Pre-Chorus)
Now every time somebody gets too close
I start looking for a reason they’ll go
(Chorus)
’Cause you left scars where your hands used to be
Turned “I love you” into something weak
Now every girl that tries to hold my soul
Feels the distance I can’t control
I want to trust, I want to fall
But your goodbye still haunts it all
You broke me slow, then disappeared
Now I love with a second hand heart full of fear
(Verse 2)
I met somebody good the other night
She smiled at me like things might be alright
But when she touched me I pulled away
Like pain was waiting behind her eyes
It ain’t her fault you changed my mind
On what love is supposed to feel like
Now I read between every line
Expecting goodbye every time
(Pre-Chorus)
And I hate that you still have that kind of power
Even after all these hours
(Chorus)
’Cause you left scars where your hands used to be
Turned “I love you” into something weak
Now every girl that tries to hold my soul
Feels the distance I can’t control
I want to trust, I want to fall
But your goodbye still haunts it all
You broke me slow, then disappeared
Now I love with a second hand heart full of fear
(Bridge)
Maybe one day I’ll stop waiting
For the people I love to leave
Maybe one day somebody’s arms
Won’t feel like a thing to survive through
But right now
I still flinch at forever
Still drown in what we were together
(Final Chorus)
Yeah you left scars where your hands used to be
And part of me still wears your memory
But I’m trying to believe there’s more
Than bleeding on somebody who’s innocent before
And maybe love ain’t gone for good
Maybe I’m just learning how to trust again like I should
But you changed the man I see in mirrors every year
Now I love with a second hand heart full of fear.