[Verse 1]
I came home early, boots on the floor,
Saw his truck parked right by the door.
Milk crates stacked, bottles gleamin' bright,
But it wasn’t just dairy delivered that night.
[Chorus]
Caught in the cream, she was churnin' lies,
With the milk man’s smile and his baby blue eyes.
She thought I’d crumble, fall apart at the seams,
But I got my revenge, caught in the cream.
[Verse 2]
Took her good boots, swapped the left for the right,
Changed the locks on her car in the dead of night.
Her favorite lipstick, I tossed in the well,
And her hair dryer’s blowin’ cold as hell.
[Prechorus]
A little payback, just enough sting,
To remind her of every little thing.
[Chorus]
Caught in the cream, she was churnin' lies,
With the milk man’s smile and his baby blue eyes.
She thought I’d crumble, fall apart at the seams,
But I got my revenge, caught in the cream.
[Bridge]
I cancelled her shows, turned off her phone,
Signed her up for spam she’d never condone.
Put hot sauce in her morning tea,
Now she knows not to mess with me.