[Verse 1]
We were kids in Sunday shoes
Kissing by the river bend
You said
"This is it for me"
I believed every word you meant
[Verse 2]
Suitcase by the screen door light
Dust still dancing where you turned
You took the map
I kept the town
Now my board porch coffee burns
[Chorus]
You left but I stayed
You ran while I prayed
For that first love to circle back home someday
My heart never strayed
Still parked in your shade
You left
You left
But I stayed
[Verse 3]
Picture fading on my wall
Your name carved in the old oak rail
I trace the letters
Bite my tongue
Taste that promise gone so pale
[Bridge]
How can the same two hands
Hold a halo
Hold a blade? (oh)
You blessed me with my first sweet touch
Then broke me with the mess you made
[Chorus]
You left but I stayed
You ran while I prayed
For that first love to circle back home someday
My heart never strayed
Still parked in your shade
You left
You left
But I stayed
[Outro]
[Hummed vocal over soft guitar]
Hmm-mm
First love
First ache
Hmm-mm
This old heart won’t break
You left
You left
But I stayed