[Verse 1]
You sneak in
Shoes in your hand
Laughing
Lip gloss on your collar
And you're saying that you hate the act you’re acting
She’s posting Friday flowers
You’re stripping off my shirt
You call her “almost perfect”
Then you say that I’m the one who hurts
[Chorus]
So why you gonna waste your life on Hollie
When you’re in my bed screaming that you want me
You say you love me
Say you’re sorry
You say you’d leave her if it wasn’t so messy
Quit pretending that you’re stuck
You’re free
You kiss her mouth but you breathe with me
If you love me
Then you gotta choose me
Choose me
Not Hollie (hey!)
[Verse 2]
You text me
“Door’s locked
Come around back”
Your hoodie on my body
While her picture’s on your dash
You’re swearing “this means nothing”
While you’re shaking in my hands
You tell me “you’re my future”
But you’re still playing house with her plans
[Chorus]
So why you gonna waste your life on Hollie
When you’re in my bed screaming that you want me
You say you love me
Say you’re sorry
You say you’d leave her if it wasn’t so messy
Quit pretending that you’re stuck
You’re free
You kiss her mouth but you breathe with me
If you love me
Then you gotta choose me
Choose me
Not Hollie
[Bridge]
How long you gonna hide us?
How long you gonna lie?
You say you “don’t wanna hurt her”
But I’m the one you leave at night
You can’t love two
That’s a story
So pick a page you’re gonna be
‘Cause she’s holding onto history
And I’m holding onto you and me (woah)
[Chorus]
So why you gonna waste your life on Hollie
When you’re in my bed screaming that you want me
You say you love me
Say you’re sorry
You say you’d leave her if it wasn’t so messy
Quit pretending that you’re stuck
You’re free
You kiss her mouth but you breathe with me
If you love me
Then you gotta choose me
Choose me
Not Hollie
Choose me
Not Hollie (hey!)
Choose me
Choose me
Not Hollie