[Verse 1: Him]
You kept your blue coat by the doorway
I kept my train card in the drawer
We made a home out of phone calls
Then missed each other by one more
You had a Tuesday in Chicago
I had a Friday in Madrid
Every promise wore a different date
Every date became a myth
[Pre-Chorus: Her]
I loved you in the spaces
Between the leaving and the flight
[Chorus: Both]
If the hour had held still
If the road had bent our way
I would be waking beside you
Not rehearsing what to say
We were real, we were ready
Just never ready at the same time
You were the right kind of forever
In the wrong part of my life
[Verse 2: Her]
I found your note inside my cookbook
Four words beneath a grocery list
“Call me when the world gets quiet”
But the world was never kind like this
[Verse 2: Him]
I saw your picture near the harbor
Your hair was shorter than before
I typed, “I’m still here, if you need me”
Then watched the message fade unsent once more
[Pre-Chorus: Both]
Some doors don’t close from anger
They close because the seasons turn
[Chorus: Both]
If the hour had held still
If the road had bent our way
I would be waking beside you
Not rehearsing what to say
We were real, we were ready
Just never ready at the same time
You were the right kind of forever
In the wrong part of my life
[Bridge: Him]
Maybe love is not the staying
Maybe love is what remains
[Bridge: Her]
A name I don’t say in the kitchen
A hand I still reach for in sleep
[Bridge: Both]
If we meet again, don’t ask me
Whether I wondered all these years
I’ll just hold you for a minute
And let the answer disappear
[Final Chorus: Both]
If the hour had held still
If the road had bent our way
I would be waking beside you
With your coffee by the sink each day
We were real, we were ready
Just never ready at the same time
You were the right kind of forever
In the wrong part of my life
[Outro: Her]
Still, when the evening finds me
I leave one chair beside mine
[Outro: Him]
Not waiting for tomorrow
Just honoring the almost-time