[Verse 1]
Mhmm, mmm…
2 AM conversations got me feeling some way
Pour another drink, let the tension fade
Got me reminiscing 'bout the choices I made
You were mine for the week
Had me down on my knees
Still you act like it’s nothing to you
You had me caught between leaving and holding on
If you wanted forever, why you acting so gone?
Boy, you make it so hard to know where I belong
[Pre-Chorus]
Got me reading between every line that you say
And I hate that I still wanna hear you say my name
It’s 2 AM and I’m not okay
I keep coming back anyway
[Chorus]
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
We keep running out of time
Wrong place, wrong time
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
All this chemistry inside
Wrong place, wrong time
[Verse 2]
Driving past your house, it’s quarter to nine
Thinking of ways to make you mine
Reminiscing about the time you had me
In the Passenger seat, hand on my thighs
Talking ’bout dreams while the hours pass by
If loving you’s wrong, I ain’t asking why
Just let the night take us wherever tonight
Same old issues, different timing
We keep circling, never deciding
[Pre-Chorus]
Got me reading between every line that you say
And I hate that I still wanna hear you say my name
It’s 2 AM and I’m not okay
I keep coming back anyway
[Chorus]
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
We keep running out of time
Wrong place, wrong time
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
All this chemistry inside
Wrong place, wrong time
[Bridge]
We spend our hours going round in circles
Same old issues, different timing
Tell me if your heart is somewhere else now
'Cause I’m still here trying
[Final Chorus]
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
We keep running out of time
Wrong place, wrong time
Why can’t I make you mine?
Why can’t I make you mine?
2 AM got me losing my mind
Why can’t I make you mine?
