[Verse]
You fly inside it
My heart
(oo-yeah!)
Knew it from the very start
(uh-huh!)
But you only played the part—ain’t that cold?
Maybe didn’t realize
Maybe it’s all in my eyes
You and me
Together? Hearts in disguise!
[Chorus]
Hearts in disguise
Oh
Baby
Oh my! (uh!)
Was it real
Or just a lie? (whoo!)
I fantasized
You hypnotized
But now I see those hearts disguised!
(Hearts! Disguised!)
[Verse 2]
Late at night
I feel the groove
(oo-yeah!)
But the rhythm don’t approve
(nah-nah!)
Our love was slick
But not so smooth
Oh no!
Mirror-ball reflections shine
Thought I saw your heart in mine
But the mask was there the whole dang time!
[Prechorus]
Did you feel it? (Feel it!)
Did you mean it? (Mean it!)
Or was I dreaming while you scheming?
[Chorus]
Hearts in disguise
Oh
Baby
Oh my! (say what?)
Was it real
Or just a lie? (whoo!)
I fantasized
You hypnotized
But now I see those hearts disguised!
(Hearts! Disguised!)
[Bridge]
You played me like a funky beat
(uh-huh!)
Two-step shuffle
Then retreat! (oh no!)
Was it love or just deceit? (tell me!)
Ooo
Baby
Truth’s bittersweet!