[Verse 1]
You’re pacing circles in your mind
I watch the weather in your eyes
All those “what ifs” hanging heavy
Till I pull you back to now
You say you’re broken in the middle
I just laugh and take your hand
‘Cause every crack you try to hide
Fits the pieces that I am
[Chorus]
You’re the overthinker of my heart
Spinning in your head
Tearing doubts apart
But when you hold me close
It all feels right
Like all the stars fell down tonight
You’re the overthinker of my heart
And I’m complete inside your arms
[Verse 2]
We’re driving nowhere after midnight
Old songs humming through the dash (oh yeah)
You start listing every failure
I just kiss you through the crash
You talk in circles ‘bout the future
I trace my name along your sleeve
You say “what if this is fleeting?”
I say “look at me
Just breathe”
[Chorus]
You’re the overthinker of my heart
Spinning in your head
Tearing doubts apart
But when you hold me close
It all feels right
Like all the stars fell down tonight
You’re the overthinker of my heart
And I’m complete inside your arms
[Bridge]
Every tangled thought
I’ll stay
I’ll stay
Count them one by one
Till they fade away
Every sleepless night
Lay it on my chest (hey!)
Baby
You’re my question
And somehow
I’m your yes
[Chorus]
You’re the overthinker of my heart
Spinning in your head
Tearing doubts apart
But when you hold me close
It all feels right
Like all the stars fell down tonight
You’re the overthinker of my heart
And I’m complete inside your arms
You’re the overthinker of my heart
All the stars
And all I want