[Verse 1]
I remember the day you walked through my door
Thought I found what I was looking for
But you played a game right from the start
Left me standing here with a broken heart
[Pre-Chorus]
I gave you all my trust
You turned it into dust
Now every little thing
Brings me back to us
[Chorus]
I should never, I should never
Let you stay that close
I should never, I should never
Held on to what I hoped
You said my name like a promise
Then you let it fall apart
I should never, I should never
Gave you my broken heart
[Verse 2]
Same old shoes by the front door
Same cold space on the floor
I still hear your keys at night
But it’s only my mind
[Pre-Chorus]
I gave you all my trust
You turned it into dust
Now every little thing
Brings me back to us
[Chorus]
I should never, I should never
Let you stay that close
I should never, I should never
Held on to what I hoped
You said my name like a promise
Then you let it fall apart
I should never, I should never
Gave you my broken heart
[Bridge]
If love was a lesson
You taught it too well
Now I pick up the pieces
From the weight of your spell
[Final Chorus]
I should never, I should never
Let you stay that close
I should never, I should never
Held on to what I hoped
You said my name like a promise
Then you let it fall apart
I should never, I should never
Gave you my broken heart