(Verse 1)
We were kids pretending we were grown,
Heart on fire, but I kept throwin’ stones.
Three times I broke you like it meant nothin’,
Three times you came back like my pain was somethin’.
You held my chaos like it was gold,
I pushed you away, you still wouldn't let go.
Girl, I swear I was drowning in my own fear,
And you kept whispering, “I’m still here.”
(Pre-Chorus)
But you’re with someone else now,
And I’m just a ghost in your crowd.
Still you look at me with those eyes…
Like you never learned goodbye.
(Chorus)
Dumb girl, why you still forgiving me?
Every time I broke us, you kept believing me.
He’s holding your hand, but I know your heart still hurts,
We’re both pretending like it could ever work.
Maybe not this life, maybe not this earth,
But maybe we’ll be together in another universe.
Where I don’t break you,
And you don’t save me.
Where love’s not a war,
And our past can’t chase me.
(Verse 2)
I feel guilty every night I breathe,
Knowing you loved a version of me
That I wasn’t strong enough to be.
You kept choosing me, even when it killed you,
I kept losing me, even when I felt you.
He treats you better, that’s what they all say,
But you still look back at me anyway.
We’re tied together in a way that hurts,
Two souls stuck in the wrong universe.
(Pre-Chorus)
If I could restart time,
Rewrite every line,
You wouldn’t cry because of my mistakes—
I’d love you with no breaks.
(Chorus)
Dumb girl, why you still forgiving me?
Every time I broke us, you kept believing me.
He’s holding your hand, but I know your heart still burns,
We keep running back even when nobody learns.
Maybe not this life, maybe not this earth,
But maybe we’ll be together in another universe.
Where I don’t break you,
And you don’t save me.
Where love’s not a wound,
And our memories don’t blame me.
(Bridge)
Maybe we’re soulmates with the wrong timing,
Maybe we’re love notes that kept rewinding.
Maybe I hurt you ‘cause I didn’t know how to love,
But damn, you loved me more than enough.
If there’s a world where we finally get it right,
I swear I’ll find you there one night.
(Final Chorus)
Dumb girl, why you still forgiving me?
Even now your heart keeps calling me.
You’re with someone else, but you still wear my scars,
And I still wish we weren’t living so far
From who we used to be, from what we deserved—
Maybe we’ll fit again in another universe.
Where I don’t break you,
And you don’t chase me.
Where we don’t lose love
Before it can save me.
(Outro)
Yeah… maybe another lifetime,
Maybe another sky.
But in this one…
All I can do is feel the guilt and say goodbye.
