

Prompt / Lyrics
Verse 1 He was front porch sunsets and gravel road dust A steady hand I thought I could trust Said all the right words, wore that old ball cap But forever ain’t something you take back Pre-Chorus I saw a future in his eyes so blue Guess I wasn’t the picture he was looking to Chorus He should’ve been my forever, my always and amen But he chose a wildfire I could never pretend She’s everything I ain’t, yeah, the opposite of me Where I’m quiet, she’s reckless, where I stay, she runs free Now I’m just a memory he let slip away While he’s chasing a storm I could never be He should’ve been my forever… but he chose her over me Verse 2 I was small-town roots, Sunday morning grace She’s neon lights and a fast-paced chase I held him close when the world got hard She deals in hearts like a deck of cards Pre-Chorus I gave him love that was tried and true Guess he needed something I could never do Chorus He should’ve been my forever, my always and amen But he chose a wildfire I could never pretend She’s everything I ain’t, yeah, the opposite of me Where I’m steady, she’s chaos, like a runaway breeze Now I’m just a story he don’t wanna replay While he’s dancing with a flame I could never be He should’ve been my forever… but he chose her over me Bridge Maybe one day when the smoke clears out He’ll see what love was all about But I won’t be waiting where he left my heart Some things break and stay apart Final Chorus He should’ve been my forever, but forever slipped away He traded in a home for a high he couldn’t stay She’s everything I ain’t, and I won’t try to be ‘Cause the right kind of love won’t make you feel like me Now I’m closing the door, letting go of what could be He should’ve been my forever… But forever ain’t him for me Outro Yeah, forever ain’t him… And that’s how it’s gonna be
Tags
Female country heart felt ballad
4:05
No
3/29/2026