[Verse]
Saw him in the hallway leaning by the door
Black hair like midnight freckles galore
His blue eyes caught me staring oh no not again
Why does my heart race like it's in a whirlwind
[Prechorus]
He's one year older
But it feels like a world
I'm just thirteen
Just a daydream girl
[Chorus]
Blue-eyed mystery
You're a puzzle to me
Freckles like constellations I can barely see
Every glance feels like it's meant to be
Oh blue-eyed mystery
Do you notice me
[Verse 2]
He laughs with his friends
It's a melody sweet
I fumble my locker
Trip over my feet
His voice echoes softly like a song in the air
I wonder if he even knows I'm there
[Prechorus]
His shadow feels taller
But I don’t feel small
In my dreams I can hear him call
[Chorus]
Blue-eyed mystery
You're a puzzle to me
Freckles like constellations I can barely see
Every glance feels like it's meant to be
Oh blue-eyed mystery
Do you notice me