[Verse 1]
Met you in the doorway
Wristband
Stamp
Blue light on your face
Laughing like you knew me
Like we'd skipped ten steps
Cut straight to fate
You said
"Where you headed?"
I said
"Too far from where I wanna be"
Your hand brushed my jacket
And time did a glitch on me
[Pre-Chorus]
If this was five years later
If this was five years ago
Maybe I'd be braver
Maybe I would let this go
But I got bags packed in the back of a cab
And you got hearts calling you back
[Chorus]
You're the right heart
Wrong night
Right words
Wrong life
In another universe
We'd be driving home first light
You're the right song
Wrong show
Right "stay"
Wrong "I gotta go"
I can feel us catching fire
But I gotta let you fly
Right heart
Wrong night
[Verse 2]
You wrote your number sideways
On my wrist like some small dare
Said
"If you ever come back
Maybe I'll still be here"
We danced past last orders
Spinning through a maybe and a might
Every laugh
Every shoulder touch
Felt like stealing from a future life
[Pre-Chorus]
If this was clean-slate summer
If this was after the storm
Maybe I'd say "come with"
Maybe we'd rewrite the form
But I got one-way written on my phone
And you got reasons to stay home
[Chorus]
You're the right heart
Wrong night
Right words
Wrong life
In another universe
We'd be driving home first light
You're the right song
Wrong show
Right "stay"
Wrong "I gotta go"
I can feel us catching fire
But I gotta let you fly
Right heart
Wrong night
[Bridge]
[Beat pulls back
Filtered vocal]
Close my eyes
I see
What we almost were
Two rings
One key
Whole world in a three-word "sure"
(open up, open up, open up)
[Chorus]
You're the right heart
Wrong night
Right turn
Wrong light
Somewhere on a different road
We don't have to say goodbye
You're the right song
Wrong show
Right "stay"
Wrong "I gotta go"
I'll be thinking of your smile
Every time they kill the lights
Right heart
Wrong night (oh)
Right heart
Wrong night