[Verse 1]
There’s plenty of fish
Out in the sea
But the one I caught
Just isn’t it for me
She smiled like a trap
With salt on her lips
Now every blue wave
Feels like a threat on my skin
[Pre-Chorus]
She taught me one thing
Don’t look back out there
So I keep my eyes low
But the pull’s still there
[Chorus]
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
She left a bruise
On my ocean sea
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
I caught the wrong one
And it won’t let me be
[Verse 2]
Sitting in the water
Lost in my mind
Knee-deep in the cold
With the moon behind
I hear her laugh
In the pull of the tide
Every rip in the dark
Feels like her coming back inside
[Pre-Chorus]
She taught me one thing
Don’t look back out there
So I keep my hands clenched
But the pull’s still there
[Chorus]
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
She left a bruise
On my ocean sea
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
I caught the wrong one
And it won’t let me be
[Bridge]
[Half-time]
Water up to my chest
And I’m biting my tongue
Thought love was a net
Now I’m tearing one by one
If I see that blue again
I might run ashore
’Cause the deep looked kind
When it dragged me under before
[Final Chorus]
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
She left a bruise
On my ocean sea
Plenty of fish, but not for me
Plenty of fish, but not for me
I caught the wrong one
And it won’t let me be