[Verse 1]
We met on a Tuesday
Rain on your red coat sleeves
You laughed at my bad jokes
Like you already knew me
You said
"Name's Keeley"
I said it twice so it would stay
Now it's carved on every barstool
Every slow song I play
[Chorus]
Keeley
Keeley
Why you keep me so blue?
Got this old heart leaning
Like it’s missing a shoe
Keeley
Keeley
I still talk to that empty room
If you ever come back
Darling
Bring some sunlight to this gloom (hey)
[Verse 2]
Your coffee cup's still on the counter
Lipstick ring half gone
That crooked little Polaroid
I leave the porch light on
These walls remember your footsteps
My shirts remember your scent
I remember saying "forever"
You remember how you left
[Chorus]
Keeley
Keeley
Why you keep me so blue?
Every clock in this house
Stopped the day I lost you
Keeley
Keeley
I still hum your favorite tune
If you ever come back
Darling
Bring some sunlight to this gloom
[Bridge]
Maybe you're out there laughing
At some old movie line
Maybe you don't think about me
But you still live in my mind
I pour two drinks in the evening
Then I drink yours too
To the ghost of a girl named Keeley
And the man she once rode with through
[Chorus]
Keeley
Keeley
Why you keep me so blue?
Got my pride in my pocket
Got my soul in my shoes
Keeley
Keeley
If you're hearing this truth
I was born a little broken
But I was whole there next to you